Pigeon Cay Beach Club, Arthur's Town ➤ Reviews, Rooms & Prices 2025

Book on our site

Up to 10% cheaper

than Booking.com

Key details

About the Hotel

Rokers, Arthur's Town, Bahamas

Pigeon Cay Beach Club is a small private property located on Cat Island in the Bahamas, known for its beautiful, lush landscapes and inviting atmosphere. The hotel features hand-crafted, custom-designed cottages that offer a mix of privacy and Caribbean charm. This location provides access to some of the most stunning beaches in the Northern area of Cat Island. It is an ideal choice for travelers seeking a serene getaway surrounded by nature.

Location

Pigeon Cay Beach Club is situated approximately 12.5 miles from Arthur's Town and 6.5 miles from the nearest airport, Arthur's Town Airport. Transportation options such as car hire are available for guests wishing to explore the island further. Direct flights from Fort Lauderdale Executive to New Bight facilitate convenient access for international travelers. The surrounding area features tropical elements, including palm trees and flowers, contributing to the peaceful setting.

Rooms

All accommodations at Pigeon Cay Beach Club are air-conditioned and accessible via exterior corridors. The handcrafted cottages range from one to three bedrooms and feature open floor plans, fully equipped kitchens, and comfortable furnishings. Certain rooms offer views of the sea or garden, while others include a seating area to relax after a busy day. The Sea Studio is notable for its kitchenette, while most accommodations provide guests with complimentary bottled water and other amenities.

Eat & Drink

Guests can enjoy breakfast and dinner catered to their preferences, with meals served directly in the cottages or outdoors by the beach. The dining experience aims to highlight local flavors and fresh ingredients. For those who prefer cooking, the well-fitted kitchens in each cottage allow guests to prepare their own meals. Additionally, a small side boutique offers various local crafts and snacks for purchase.

Leisure & Business

Outdoor adventures abound at Pigeon Cay Beach Club, with free bicycles available for guests to explore the surrounding 200-acre wilderness on foot or by bike. The hotel emphasizes relaxation with access to pristine beaches for swimming and sunbathing. A small library filled with paperbacks and board games offers entertainment for those leisurely days. Fishing enthusiasts can benefit from certified Bahamian fishing guides if venturing out into the flats.

View all

Select your room type

The hotel offers a variety of rooms including double rooms, family rooms, and suites with breakfast, free cancelations, and special deals

Single Room Garden View

Max:

1 person

37 m²

Bed options:

1 Single bed

Garden view

Shower

Coffee machine

room details

Check Prices

Queen Studio

Max:

2 persons

42 m²

Bed options:

1 King-size bed

Sea view

Shower

Coffee machine

room details

Check Prices

Studio Garden View

Max:

2 persons

37 m²

Bed options:

1 King-size bed

Shower

Coffee machine

room details

Check Prices

Show all roomsLess

Price and Room Availability Calendar

Check availability and prices for your dates now!

Getting around

A list of all available modes of transport

City Centre

Arthur's Town 11.8 km

Airports

Arthurs Town (ATC) 19.8 km

The Bight (TBI) 30.8 km

Facilities

The hotel offers amenities for your comfortable stay and unforgettable experiences

Relaxing Spa Retreat

“The spa facilities were amazing, with a serene atmosphere and an incredibly rejuvenating massage.” view full review

Immaculate Room

“The room was spotless upon arrival, which made us feel immediately comfortable and at home.” view full review

Delicious Breakfast

“Breakfast offerings were diverse and flavorful, featuring freshly made pastries and a variety of healthy options.” view full review

Excellent Shower Pressure

“The shower pressure was excellent, providing a refreshing experience each morning.” view full review

General

No smoking on site
Free Wi-Fi in public areas
Free parking
Safe deposit box
24-hour reception
VIP check-in/ -out
Express check-in/ -out
Pets allowed
24-hour security
Luggage storage
Private beach
Currency exchange
Fireplace
Smoke detectors
Fire extinguishers

Sports & Fitness

Snorkelling
Canoeing
Hiking
Cycling
Badminton
Fishing

Guest Parking

Electric kettle
Cookware/ Kitchen utensils

Services

Paid airport shuttle
Room service
Housekeeping
Car hire
Laundry
Tours/Ticket assistance
Grocery shopping service
Happy hour

Dining

In-room breakfast
Restaurant
Bar/ Lounge area
Outdoor dining area
Picnic area/ Tables
Special diet menus

Business

Business centre
Meeting/ Banquet facilities
Fax/Photocopying

Children

Babysitting/Child services
Board games
Children's play area

Spa & Leisure

Beach access
Sun terrace
Garden area
BBQ facilities
Massage

Room features

Air conditioning
Sitting area
Dressing area
Patio
Terrace
Garden furniture
Tea and coffee facilities
Dining table
Ironing facilities

Bathroom

Free toiletries

Self-catering

Electric kettle
Cookware/ Kitchen utensils

Media

Flat-screen TV
CD player
AM/FM alarm clock

Location

Rokers, Arthur's Town, Bahamas

Map view

Rokers, Arthur's Town, Bahamas

City landmarks

Pigeon Cay Beach

2.9 km

Nearby

Pigeon Cay Beach

0 m

Reviews and Ratings

Feedback from previous guests about their experience.

92%

liked the hotel and would stay again

Breathtaking beach views

Knowledgeable hosts

Limited nightlife options

Remote location

9.2/10

Perfect

Rooms

9.2

Location

9.4

Service

9.8

Dining

9.0

Lee

United States, January 2025

8.8/10

Pigeon Cay Beach Club is a serene and beautiful getaway perfect for those seeking peace and stunning ocean views. The cottages are cozy and charming, with lovely beachfront access. However, be cautious if you're not a guest, as the owner can be rather unfriendly to visitors. Overall, this place is great for relaxation, but the exclusivity may be a downside for some.

Rooms

8.0

The cottages are very nice, comfy, but not fancy. Each has a lovely porch to enjoy meals or drinks with a soothing view of the sea.

Service

9.0

The hosts, Leslie and Ned, are welcoming and accommodating. Their hospitality makes you feel at home, but some visitors may not feel welcome if they are not guests.

Location

9.0

Located on a beautiful beach with soft white sand, it's the perfect spot for unwinding. However, it's necessary to stay on the property to enjoy full access.

Dining

Facilities

9.0

The amenities, like kayaks and loungers, are free and easily accessible. It's eco-friendly too, which is a big plus.

Steve

United States, December 2024

9.0/10

Pigeon Cay is an absolute hidden gem! With stunning beach access just steps away and a cozy atmosphere, it offers an unforgettable experience. The hosts, Leslie and Ned, create an inviting environment and provide delicious meals. The only drawback could be that it might not suit those looking for a bustling nightlife or luxury resort vibe.

Rooms

9.0

The Sea Studio was small yet very comfortable, and I loved the convenience of having a kitchen for meals.

Service

10.0

Leslie was incredibly helpful with everything from coordinating activities to ensuring we had what we needed during our stay.

Location

10.0

Pigeon Cay is perfectly situated right on the beach, making it feel wonderfully remote and peaceful, away from cruise ship traffic.

Dining

10.0

Dinner cooked by Leslie and Ned was always fantastic, with special themed nights that made meals memorable.

Facilities

10.0

The range of amenities like kayaks and paddle boards made our stay even more enjoyable, offering plenty of activities right on the property.

Emily

United States, October 2024

9.2/10

Pigeon Cay Beach Club offers a magical experience on Cat Island with its stunning, secluded beach and charming cottages. The laid-back atmosphere was perfect for relaxation, and the hosts, Leslie and Ned, made us feel right at home. We loved the complimentary use of paddle boards and kayaks, which added to our fun. However, there's a downside as the location might not suit everyone’s taste for more vibrant activity options nearby.

Rooms

9.0

The cottages are comfortable, clean, and whimsically decorated, making them feel very inviting.

Service

10.0

Leslie and Ned were incredibly helpful, assisting with car rentals and local tips without being intrusive.

Location

9.0

The location is beautifully secluded with a stunning beach, perfect for those seeking tranquility.

Dining

8.0

The option for arranged dinners at the Club was delightful, and the local dining scene was charming.

Facilities

9.0

The free beach equipment for guests was a fantastic addition to our stay, allowing for more fun in the sun.

Paul

United States, August 2024

9.8/10

This hotel is a true slice of paradise, offering breathtaking beach views and a calm, relaxing atmosphere. The cottages are well-equipped and homey, providing everything you might need. The service from Leslie and Ned stands out, as they are incredibly welcoming and knowledgeable about the area. However, if you're looking for an active nightlife, this might not be the place for you, as it leans more towards a peaceful retreat. Overall, the experience is absolutely worth the price considering the variety of amenities and intimate island vibe.

Rooms

10.0

The cottages provided all the essentials, including a fully furnished kitchen and ample towels for both showering and beach time.

Service

10.0

Leslie and Ned went above and beyond to assist with tours, car rentals, and answering any questions we had about our stay.

Location

10.0

The hotel is located on a secluded beach with powdery white sand and no one in sight for miles, truly an escape from the hustle and bustle.

Dining

9.0

We enjoyed delicious homemade meals; breakfast and dinner were both well-prepared, and there was also flexibility to eat in our cottage.

Facilities

10.0

The amenities included canoes, kayaks, and a self-service bar, making it easy to enjoy various activities all in one place.

Breathtaking beach views

Limited nightlife options

Tim

United States, August 2024

9.6/10

I had a wonderful time at Pigeon Cay, but it’s important to note that it’s not the typical resort experience you might expect. The beach is absolutely breathtaking, with powdery white sand and hardly anyone around, making it perfect for relaxation. On the downside, if you're looking for lively entertainment and social scenes, this place may not suit you. Overall, I found great value for money in my stay, especially given the peaceful environment and hospitality.

Rooms

10.0

The cottages were charming and artistically decorated, giving a cozy yet unique feel. They were right by the beach, providing easy access for a morning swim.

Service

10.0

The owners, Leslie and Ned, went above and beyond to ensure we had a fantastic experience, offering help with tours and providing detailed information about the island.

Location

9.0

Pigeon Cay is set in a serene location with a beautiful stretch of beach that feels secluded and private. It perfectly captures the essence of island life, though traveling here may require some planning.

Dining

9.0

We enjoyed delicious meals at the bar, and having the option to eat in our cottage was a nice touch. The dining experience added to the warm, welcoming vibe of our stay.

Facilities

10.0

The facility offers complimentary water sports like kayaking, which are perfect for exploring the calm waters. The overall atmosphere is tranquil, which enhances the experience.